The Matters Ledger

The record,
such as we may state it

Every matter we are free to describe, since the firm’s first year. Where a client’s identity is confidential the description is generic and the value is given as a band. Sort any column; filter by practice or year; the summary of the current row is set in the margin.

How to read it

Matter numbers run HV / year / sequence. Value bands are the amount in issue, not the fee. “Advisory” means no proceedings were commenced.

01The ledger

2019–2026

41 matters

Matters of Harcourt Vane LLP, 2019 to 2026. Use the column heads to sort, the arrow keys to move between rows and Enter to expand a row.
2026 HV/2026/031 Panel reference Art Advising a Geneva foundation on the restitution of a 1912 Schiele drawing Undisclosed Advisory

The drawing left Vienna in 1938 and surfaced at a Basel fair in 2019. We advised on title, on the Washington Principles, and on a settlement that left the work on public display in Switzerland.

Art and cultural property · Undisclosed · Lead: Tobias Lindgren

2026 HV/2026/004 Upper Tribunal Regulatory Representing a senior manager in an FCA enforcement investigation Undisclosed Respondent

The Authority alleged a failure to take reasonable steps under SMCR in relation to a trade surveillance system. We are contesting the case at the Upper Tribunal after warning notice.

Regulatory and investigations · Undisclosed · Lead: Miriam Sassoon

2026 HV/2026/019 LCIA Arbitration Acting for an offshore wind developer in a turbine supply arbitration £25–100m Claimant

Blade delamination across two Baltic sites raised questions of design defect and of the limits in a supply agreement drafted in 2019. The tribunal was constituted in March 2026.

International arbitration · £25–100m · Lead: Rosalind Achebe

2026 HV/2026/046 Chancery Division Wealth Acting for beneficiaries in a claim against retired trustees of a Manx settlement £25–100m Claimant

The trustees retired in 2016 without taking a chain of indemnities. The claim concerns the distribution of a private company shareholding at a valuation nobody now defends.

Private wealth and trusts · £25–100m · Lead: Beatrice Fairley

2026 HV/2026/058 Commercial Court Disputes Defending a commodities trader in a claim on a repo financing arrangement £100m+ Defendant

The dispute turns on whether a series of repurchase agreements was, as the bank contends, a single secured facility. Trial is listed for the Michaelmas term 2027.

Commercial disputes · £100m+ · Lead: Clara Whitfield

2025 HV/2025/012 LCIA Arbitration Acting for a shipping group in a USD 240m LCIA arbitration on a charterparty £100m+ Claimant

A ten-year time charter was repudiated three years into its term after a sanctions designation affected the charterer’s parent. The award was published in February 2026.

International arbitration · £100m+ · Lead: Anand Mehta

2025 HV/2025/067 Chancery Division Wealth Defending a family office in Chancery proceedings concerning a Jersey trust £25–100m Defendant

Two of five beneficiaries allege that the trustee’s investment policy favoured the settlor’s second family. The claim was stayed in November 2025 for mediation.

Private wealth and trusts · £25–100m · Lead: Julian Vane

2025 HV/2025/098 Media & Comms Media Acting for a broadcaster in a defamation claim over a safety investigation Under £5m Defendant

A housebuilder sued over a documentary alleging systemic failures in fire-stopping. We succeeded on meaning at a preliminary issue trial and the claim was discontinued.

Reputation and media · Under £5m · Lead: Henry Okonkwo

2025 HV/2025/023 Commercial Court Disputes Acting for a reinsurer on the aggregation of pandemic business interruption losses £100m+ Claimant

Some 2,400 underlying claims were presented as a single event. The court accepted our construction of the hours clause in a judgment handed down in July 2025.

Commercial disputes · £100m+ · Lead: Eleanor Harcourt KC

2025 HV/2025/074 ICC Paris Arbitration Representing a Gulf contractor in a delayed desalination plant reference £25–100m Respondent

The employer claimed liquidated damages for a nineteen-month delay; we ran concurrent delay and a prevention argument. The tribunal reduced the claim by 71 per cent.

International arbitration · £25–100m · Lead: Rosalind Achebe

2025 HV/2025/109 Advisory Art Advising an estate on the consignment and sale of a modern British collection £5–25m Advisory

Forty-one works were consigned to two houses on different terms; one auctioneer had taken a third party guarantee it had not disclosed. We renegotiated the agreements before the catalogue closed.

Art and cultural property · £5–25m · Lead: Sam Kowalczyk

2025 HV/2025/140 Court of Appeal Regulatory Appealing a production order made against a professional services firm Undisclosed Appellant

The order swept up material over which legal advice privilege was claimed by a third party. The Court of Appeal narrowed the order and gave guidance on the scope of section 2 notices.

Regulatory and investigations · Undisclosed · Lead: Inès Moreau

2024 HV/2024/117 Chancery Division Disputes Acting for the majority shareholder in a £62m unfair prejudice petition £25–100m Respondent

A family printing group of three generations divided over a proposed sale to a private equity buyer. The petition settled on a share purchase at a court-directed valuation.

Commercial disputes · £25–100m · Lead: Eleanor Harcourt KC

2024 HV/2024/088 ICC Paris Arbitration Representing a state utility in a gas offtake dispute seated in Paris £100m+ Respondent

The claimant sought damages for shortfall deliveries across four contract years. The tribunal held that force majeure was properly declared for two of them.

International arbitration · £100m+ · Lead: Anand Mehta

2024 HV/2024/173 Chancery Division Art Acting for a dealer in a claim over the attribution of a Neapolitan altarpiece £5–25m Defendant

The buyer alleged that the work was a workshop copy and sought rescission six years after sale. The claim failed on limitation and on the evidence of two conservators.

Art and cultural property · £5–25m · Lead: Tobias Lindgren

2024 HV/2024/009 Grand Court, KY Wealth Advising a protector on the removal of the trustee of a £310m Cayman structure £100m+ Advisory

The protector’s power of removal had never been exercised and its scope was disputed. We advised on the mechanics and on the blessing application that followed.

Private wealth and trusts · £100m+ · Lead: Julian Vane

2024 HV/2024/052 FCA review Regulatory Conducting a privileged internal review for a payments business Undisclosed Advisory

A whistleblower alleged that transaction monitoring alerts had been closed without review. The review covered 14 months of alerts and was disclosed to the regulator in part.

Regulatory and investigations · Undisclosed · Lead: Miriam Sassoon

2024 HV/2024/121 Commercial Court Disputes Defending a specialist insurer on the construction of an aggregation clause £25–100m Defendant

The insured sought to treat 63 mis-selling complaints as one claim. The court agreed with our reading of ‘related acts or omissions’ and the exposure fell within a single limit.

Commercial disputes · £25–100m · Lead: Clara Whitfield

2024 HV/2024/164 SIAC Arbitration Acting for a Singapore trading house in a metals warehousing dispute £5–25m Claimant

Warrants had been issued against stock that could not be located at two warehouses. The tribunal found the warehouse operator liable in conversion.

International arbitration · £5–25m · Lead: Anand Mehta

2024 HV/2024/199 Media & Comms Media Obtaining an injunction restraining publication of confidential medical information Under £5m Claimant

An employee’s diagnosis had been passed to a trade publication by a former colleague. The order was made at a hearing convened within six hours of instruction.

Reputation and media · Under £5m · Lead: Henry Okonkwo

2023 HV/2023/041 Commercial Court Disputes Advising a listed logistics group on a warranty claim after a depot acquisition £25–100m Claimant

Contamination at a Rotterdam depot had been disclosed in a data room index but not in the documents themselves. The claim settled at mediation for a sum we may not state.

Commercial disputes · £25–100m · Lead: Eleanor Harcourt KC

2023 HV/2023/119 Arts Council Art Advising a national museum on the export licensing of an Anglo-Saxon hoard £5–25m Advisory

The hoard was found by a detectorist in Suffolk and was subject to a treasure inquest before any licence question arose. A matching offer was raised in eleven weeks.

Art and cultural property · £5–25m · Lead: Tobias Lindgren

2023 HV/2023/077 Media & Comms Media Acting for a claimant in a privacy claim against a national newspaper Under £5m Claimant

The article reproduced photographs taken inside a private hospital car park. The claim settled with a statement in open court and the destruction of the images.

Reputation and media · Under £5m · Lead: Henry Okonkwo

2023 HV/2023/152 LCIA Arbitration Acting for a lender in an arbitration over a defaulted mezzanine facility £25–100m Claimant

The borrower argued that a waiver by conduct had varied the covenant package. The tribunal found there had been no waiver and awarded the principal in full.

International arbitration · £25–100m · Lead: Rosalind Achebe

2023 HV/2023/086 Chancery Division Wealth Acting in a claim to set aside appointments made under a mistake of tax law £5–25m Claimant

Appointments made in 2011 triggered an exit charge nobody had anticipated. The court set them aside on Pitt v Holt principles at an unopposed hearing.

Private wealth and trusts · £5–25m · Lead: Beatrice Fairley

2023 HV/2023/013 Upper Tribunal Regulatory Representing an approved person in a market abuse reference Undisclosed Respondent

The Authority alleged improper disclosure of inside information in a series of messages. The reference was withdrawn after we produced the full message thread in context.

Regulatory and investigations · Undisclosed · Lead: Inès Moreau

2022 HV/2022/206 Commercial Court Disputes Acting for a bank in a claim arising from a failed trade finance programme £100m+ Defendant

Receivables purchased under the programme were alleged never to have existed. The claim was compromised on the second day of a six-week trial.

Commercial disputes · £100m+ · Lead: Clara Whitfield

2022 HV/2022/141 Royal Court GY Wealth Acting for beneficiaries in a Beddoe application in the Royal Court of Guernsey £5–25m Advisory

The trustee sought directions before defending a claim brought by a former spouse of the settlor. Directions were given and the costs regime settled in advance.

Private wealth and trusts · £5–25m · Lead: Julian Vane

2022 HV/2022/078 ICSID Arbitration Advising a mining company on treaty protection following a licence revocation £100m+ Claimant

A concession granted in 2014 was revoked without compensation after a change of administration. We advised on the treaty route and on the corporate restructuring that preceded it.

International arbitration · £100m+ · Lead: Anand Mehta

2022 HV/2022/031 Chancery Division Art Acting for a collector in a title dispute over a bronze acquired at auction £5–25m Claimant

The bronze had been stolen from a Tuscan church in 1979 and passed through four hands. The claim resolved with a division of the sale proceeds and the return of the work.

Art and cultural property · £5–25m · Lead: Sam Kowalczyk

2022 HV/2022/167 Internal Regulatory Advising a fund manager on a market soundings review after a leak Undisclosed Advisory

Price movement preceded three placings in eighteen months. The review found no unlawful disclosure and led to a rebuilt wall-crossing procedure.

Regulatory and investigations · Undisclosed · Lead: Miriam Sassoon

2021 HV/2021/154 Commercial Court Arbitration Resisting enforcement of a Stockholm award against an energy trader £25–100m Respondent

Enforcement was resisted on the ground that the tribunal had decided a question not put to it. The court enforced in part and remitted the remainder.

International arbitration · £25–100m · Lead: Rosalind Achebe

2021 HV/2021/033 Pre-action Media Advising a family on a data protection claim after a local authority disclosure Under £5m Advisory

A children’s services file was sent to the wrong address and read by a neighbour. The authority admitted the breach and compensation was agreed without proceedings.

Reputation and media · Under £5m · Lead: Henry Okonkwo

2021 HV/2021/092 Court of Appeal Disputes Appealing the construction of an indemnity in a share purchase agreement £25–100m Appellant

At first instance the indemnity was read as capped by a general liability clause. The Court of Appeal disagreed and restored the full measure of recovery.

Commercial disputes · £25–100m · Lead: Eleanor Harcourt KC

2021 HV/2021/118 Advisory Wealth Advising on the governance of a fourth-generation family holding company £100m+ Advisory

Thirty-one shareholders across three branches had no agreed exit mechanism. We drafted a constitution, a valuation formula and a standing family council.

Private wealth and trusts · £100m+ · Lead: Beatrice Fairley

2020 HV/2020/188 Crown Court Regulatory Advising a construction group on a deferred prosecution agreement with the SFO £25–100m Advisory

Payments through an intermediary in two overseas markets were self-reported in 2019. The agreement was approved by the court in 2021 with a financial penalty and a compliance monitor.

Regulatory and investigations · £25–100m · Lead: Miriam Sassoon

2020 HV/2020/044 Commercial Court Disputes Acting for a supplier in a claim on the failure of a bespoke inventory system £5–25m Claimant

The system was accepted, used for eleven months and then rejected. The court held that the right to reject had been lost and awarded the unpaid milestones.

Commercial disputes · £5–25m · Lead: Clara Whitfield

2020 HV/2020/127 LCIA Arbitration Acting for a charterer in a demurrage and detention reference Under £5m Respondent

Laytime ran through a port closure at the start of the pandemic. The tribunal apportioned the delay and dismissed the detention claim.

International arbitration · Under £5m · Lead: Anand Mehta

2019 HV/2019/065 Chancery Division Wealth Defending trustees in a claim for breach of the duty to consider a distribution £5–25m Defendant

A discretionary beneficiary alleged that requests over four years were never put to the trustees. The minutes showed otherwise and the claim was dismissed.

Private wealth and trusts · £5–25m · Lead: Julian Vane

2019 HV/2019/021 Advisory Art Advising a museum on a long-term loan and the risk of seizure abroad Undisclosed Advisory

Twenty-two objects travelled to three jurisdictions, one without immunity from seizure legislation. The loan proceeded under an amended schedule and a state indemnity.

Art and cultural property · Undisclosed · Lead: Tobias Lindgren

2019 HV/2019/103 Court of Appeal Disputes Resisting an appeal on the enforceability of a liquidated damages regime £25–100m Respondent

The appellant argued that the regime was a penalty because it applied on termination. The appeal was dismissed and the judgment is now regularly cited.

Commercial disputes · £25–100m · Lead: Eleanor Harcourt KC